SSO Login with Google Not Working

I am having an issue with the Google login. I have this plugin setup on multiple other sites for SSO functionality only (name / email) and it works just fine. I have confirmed the miniOrange settings, security settings, Google Dev Console setup, everything. Between this site and my working site, everything is the same (except obviously the Secret & Client IDs, Callback URL), but I cannot figure out why this site is having issues. When I look at the console I am getting a 500 (Internal) error. The errors I get are: No profile data is returned from application. Please contact your administrator. I get this if there is no current authorization from Google to login (i.e. when I manually clear out the authorized apps in my Google Account or try a Google account that isn’t registered). Registration is disabled. Contact your admin. I get this if there is an authorization between Google and my website. The page I need help with: [ log in to see the link] Any luck with this? Nope